Coinbase slams SEC in closing brief over refusal to provide clear regulation

Coinbase filed a closing brief with the US Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit on May 31, challenging the SEC’s denial of its rulemaking petition.
The case revolves around a single, conclusory sentence in the SEC’s order, which “disagreed” with Coinbase’s assertion that current SEC rules are unworkable for digital asset firms.
The exchange argues that this lack of reasoned decision-making should result in vacating the regulator’s order. Additionally, Coinbase wants the court to mandate the SEC to engage in rulemaking for the crypto industry.
Coinbase Chief Legal Officer Paul Grewal emphasized the importance of this legal battle on social media and criticized the SEC for offering no substantive reasoning behind its disagreement. He said:
“The SEC’s order must be vacated on this elementary ground alone.”
Grewal highlighted the broader implications of the SEC’s stance, asserting that the SEC is overreaching its jurisdiction without clear authorization from Congress and without establishing clear rules for the burgeoning digital asset industry.
Grewal also expressed concerns about the SEC’s approach, accusing the agency of attempting to stifle the digital asset industry. He said:
“The SEC is bent on choking the digital asset industry and is refusing to provide the necessary rules the industry has requested in order to tighten the squeeze.”
This sentiment is echoed in Coinbase’s legal brief, which argues that the SEC’s actions are part of a deliberate effort to destroy an industry by enforcing compliance with unworkable regulations.
The brief filed by Coinbase contends that the SEC’s failure to engage in proper rulemaking violates the Administrative Procedure Act (APA), which requires agencies to engage in rulemaking for major policy changes.
Coinbase argues that the SEC’s policies on digital assets have been inconsistent and lack a coherent legal standard, making compliance impossible for industry participants. The brief states:
“The SEC’s position has radically and continually changed, creating uncertainty and confusion.”
The filing also highlights the agency’s contradictory statements over the years and its aggressive enforcement actions, which have targeted only a subset of digital assets without clear guidance.
Coinbase’s legal team argued that the SEC must engage in rulemaking to establish clear and workable standards for digital asset firms.
The brief points out that the SEC’s current stance effectively renders the entire digital asset industry non-compliant with existing rules, a situation that is “untenable and unfair.”
The case has drawn significant attention from the crypto community and regulatory observers, as it could have far-reaching implications for the regulation of digital assets in the US.
Coinbase’s challenge illustrates the ongoing tension between the digital assets industry and regulatory bodies as the industry seeks clarity and fair treatment under the law.
The Third Circuit’s decision on this matter will be closely watched, as it has the potential to shape the future of digital asset regulation and determine the extent of the SEC’s authority over the industry.
AJ, a passionate journalist since Yemen’s 2011 Arab Spring, has honed his skills worldwide for over a decade. Specializing in financial journalism, he now focuses on crypto reporting.
CryptoSlate is a comprehensive and contextualized source for crypto news, insights, and data. Focusing on Bitcoin, macro, DeFi and AI.

Follow us on X for instant crypto news and insights updates.
Franklin Templeton is the first to announce a sponsor fee of 0.19% for the ETF.
The lawmakers called on President Biden to either sign the resolution into law or collaborate with the SEC to revoke the guidance.
Securitize CEO Carlos Domingo confirmed he would testify at the hearing on May 31 following speculation on social media.
Bloomberg Senior ETF Eric Balchunas called an earlier mid-June launch a “long shot.”
Disclaimer: Our writers’ opinions are solely their own and do not reflect the opinion of CryptoSlate. None of the information you read on CryptoSlate should be taken as investment advice, nor does CryptoSlate endorse any project that may be mentioned or linked to in this article. Buying and trading cryptocurrencies should be considered a high-risk activity. Please do your own due diligence before taking any action related to content within this article. Finally, CryptoSlate takes no responsibility should you lose money trading cryptocurrencies.